At a time when Canada, just like every other country, is looking for highly skilled workers, our tax rates make it more difficult for them to choose to work here. This is equally true for Canadian citizens and potential new immigrants. Anecdotally, I’m hearing more and more from clients and people in my network that their children who have chosen to study abroad aren’t coming back home because they can earn and keep more of their income elsewhere. I’m not surprised.
Our high tax rates also make it hard to attract investment into our country and for existing businesses to expand. That is essential to improve productivity, innovate, create jobs and compete against peers in lower-tax jurisdictions.
The Allan Small Financial Show, featuring three tax experts—Fred O’Riordan of Ernst & Young, Jake Fuss of The Fraser Institute and Tim Cestnick, a Globe and Mail tax columnist and CEO of Our Family Office—originally aired on September 18, 2024.
Let’s explore a flat tax
We need a better, more thoughtful tax strategy as a country—one that is fair for everyone. Canada has not taken a hard, comprehensive look at our tax system since 1962, when Prime Minister John Diefenbaker appointed the Royal Commission on Taxation.
At the very least, it would be an opportunity to streamline what is a very complicated system, as I see it. At best, it may point to a better way forward. One potential way to streamline our tax system, and make it more efficient and fair, is to implement a flat tax rate across the board. This is not a new concept for taxation.
For the past decade, Estonia has reaped the rewards of having the most competitive, simple and transparent tax system in the OECD. Its personal and corporate tax rates are 20%. It’s set to increase to 22% in 2025 to match its consumption tax, which increased from 20% to 22% in 2024. In the case of individuals, the tax rate does not apply to dividend income; and businesses only pay tax on distributed profits.
The result: the country has been very successful attracting startups and investment.
And we don’t have to leave Canada for an example of a flat tax. From 2001 to 2014, Alberta had a single 10% personal and business income tax rate, dubbed the Alberta Tax Advantage. The Fraser Institute is now calling for Alberta to implement an even lower flat tax of 8% on personal and business income to attract people, businesses and investment in the province and to encourage spending. When Canadians pay less tax, they have more to spend and put back into the Canadian economy.
Another potential way to ensure tax fairness and generate revenue to meet government responsibilities is to foster more opportunities for the public, business and government to collaborate. For example, why not give individuals and businesses the ability to invest in infrastructure projects, such as new roads and highways, and get a rate of return over time.
